Haley Productions Games Logo

Murder Mystery Game Themes

Get ready for an unforgettable immersive experience with our large group murder mystery games! Check our our themes below.

Dive into the intrigue and thrill of solving a crime together while laughing the whole time.

Available for instant download! Budget friendly! Only $24.99 – $39.99. Step by step instructions and more included.

Click on any link to get more information on the large group murder mystery game theme and view a sample of the game.

A Deadly Incentive | Bordello of the Damned (Dead in Deadwood) | Diary of a Burning Woman | Final Cut | It’s a Killer Life | Murder at the Midnight Hour | Murder on Maui | My Alma Martyr | Next of Kin | Rushmore’s Revenge | Spies Like Us | The Dead Man’s Chest | The Demise of the Downhome Dealers | The Mafia Murders | Thirst for Blood | Vintage Murder | What Happened to Sam Disney?

A Deadly Incentive

A Deadly Incentive

  • Plot Summary: Seamus O’Malley hires a public relations firm to help him put his cherished yet failing pub back in the black.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • You can put this in any era you choose.
  • Great choice for St. Patrick’s Day.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Flirtation between a married man and single woman. Drunkenness.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: None. Flirtation goes to motive to commit a murder. Drunken woman reveals bad behavior and a secret.
  • Corporate adaptation: Instead of a pub make it your company.
More about the suspects & plot
Bordello Of The Damned old west large group murder mystery game

Bordello of the Damned

  • Plot Summary: Y’all are invited to Miss Iggy’s, the best little whorehouse* in Deadwood – or shall we say the deadliest? 
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Circa 1880 -The Old West at its best! (OPTION: You can put this in any era you choose.)
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Bordello/prostitutes. Former religious zealot now turned madam. Gambling theme (lost bet). Married woman sleeping with another man.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: *You can make it the best dance hall and saloon in Deadwood. The girls become can-can girls and nickel-a-dance girls. The religious zealot is completely optional. The married woman sleeping with another man is also optional but the woman still needs to be infatuated with the man.
More about the suspects & plot
The Diary Of Burning Woman Christmas large group murder mystery game

Diary of a Burning Woman

  • Plot Summary: Ebenezer Pennypincher is visited by a ghost who has a story to tell and a mystery to solve.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • You can put this in any era you choose. We like the turn of the century.
  • For your holiday party it becomes The Ghost Of Christmas Past but this script is adaptable to anytime of the year.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Affair.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: The affair can be eliminated but the 2 people must be very, very close friends to cause jealousy with the wife.
More about the suspects & plot
Final Cut Hollywood themed large group murder mystery game

Final Cut

  • Plot Summary: Director Eddie Cheek is looking for backers for his new movie so he’s throwing a gala shindig for interested parties.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Includes auditions for your guests!
  • You can put this in any era you choose.
  • Great choice for an “Academy Awards” party.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Man dressing in women’s clothes. Heterosexual and gay characters. Casting couch. Cheating and sleeping around.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: You don’t have to have the man dress in women’s clothes, he can dress as a fireman for example – anything that helps calm him in a stressful situation. The other issues can be toned down but are important to the plot.
  • Corporate adaptation: Eddie’s new movie can be about your company or your CEO and Eddie is using your employees as extras to give his movie “realism”.
More about the suspects & plot
It's a Killer Life murder mystery game

It's a Killer Life

  • Plot Summary: It’s Bellows Falls’ annual holiday party hosted at Martini’s Place. Trouble is coming to this party so only come if you dare. Our murder mystery spoof on “It’s a Wonderful Life”. Perfect for Christmas but can be modified to any time of year.
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Takes place in 1947 but you can put this in any era you choose.
  • Great choice for a Christmas/holiday party. Can be modified to any time of year and any sort of town event or party.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. One character is an angel (Clarese). Another drinks (Mary). We mention Christmas.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: Mary doesn’t have to drink but Clarese must believe she’s an angel. You can, of course, use the more generic term holiday in place of Christmas.
More about the suspects & plot
Murder At The Midnight Hour

Murder at the Midnight Hour

  • Plot Summary: Going to the chapel and we’re gonna get murdered, uh, sorry, married…Hippies and wealthy snobs just don’t mix!
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Circa 1969.
  • Great choice for New Year’s Eve. Why? The bride and groom will tie the knot in a ceremony designed to end at the stroke of midnight (kind of a hippie thing to do, is it not?). It’s do or die time now – literally – before the new year rings in.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. May/December affair. A woman who drinks too much.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: The older woman having the affair with a younger man can be toned down to her have a mid-life crisis unrequited crush on the young man. The woman who drinks too doesn’t necessarily have to although she does need to remain pretty mean and vindictive.
More about the suspects & plot
Murder On Maui

Murder on Maui

  • Plot Summary: Our luau murder mystery. You’re invited to one of Harold Logan’s (in)famous luaus and a fundraiser for HAAL, The Hawaiian Association of Authentic Leis.
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • You can put this in any era you choose. Great choice for a pool party.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Psychic character. Use of a voodoo type doll. An ex-con exotic dancer character. Gambling (minor references). Affair between stepfather and stepdaughter.
  • CONTAINS: Murders. May/December affair. A woman who drinks too much.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: The dancer can be toned down to being a waitress in a dive bar. Change the affair to an “unrequited love/crush for an older man” syndrome or the stepdaughter can be furious at her stepfather because she hoped he would actually stay married to her monster mom so she could have a dad. The gambling (card game) references are important but can be referred to then not mentioned again. The lucrative card games are why one of the characters wants to maintain ownership of a hotel. Psychic character is important. The voodoo-type doll is important.
  • This can be adapted as a corporate incentive trip
More about the suspects & plot
My Alma Martyr large group murder mystery game

My Alma Martyr

  • Plot Summary: Celebrate if you dare with Opossum State College’s Class of 1938 (or whatever year you choose). This reunion won’t be boring but you know it will be deadly. Do you dare attend?
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. A male character is somewhat abusive and mean to his wife. Flirtation (not affair) between an unhappily married woman and single man. Psychic character.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: All of these issues are important to the mystery. We don’t recommend deleting them.
More about the suspects & plot
Next of Kin

Next Of Kin

  • Plot Summary: “Big Daddy” Sugarbaker, wealthy Southern patriarch, must decide which of his wacky and worthless kin will inherit his vast estate.
  • Requires 7 to 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • EASY FOR FIRST TIMERS. EVERYONE HAS THE SAME MOTIVE: THEY ALL WANT DADDY’S MONEY.
  • You can put this in any era you choose.
  • Great choice for any sort of family gathering.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Reference to an affair. A man who is confused about his sexual identity.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: You can easily remove any reference to the man being confused about his sexual identity and any reference to the alleged affair. Neither are motives for the murders.
  • Corporate adaptation: This can be adapted to have Big Daddy become a partner in your company or be best friends with your CEO.
More about the suspects & plot
Rushmore's Revenge large group murder mystery game

Rushmore's Revenge

  • A social for the 1979 graduating class of Rushmore’s Beauty Academy for Women.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • All female cast.
  • We love to make the women English or Southern.
  • Perfect for that all-girls party or for guys that like to dress in drag.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Reference to a woman trying to kiss another woman.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: Remove the reference.
More about the suspects & plot
Spies Like Us large group murder mystery game

Spies Like Us

  • Plot Summary: Our tribute to science fiction. Dr. Ernest Terrence Mars (but you can call him E.T.) is a renowned scientist and an expert in the field of alien research. His “flu eradication drug” (if that’s what it truly is) will be the talk of the medical world after he completes Phase 2 of the testing. You and your guests are alleged “Phase 2 test subjects”.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Modern day
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. There are lover relationships in this script.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: If you’re uncomfortable with these relationships, just tone them down and tone down any dialogue you think is too suggestive.
  • Corporate adaptation: Your company has provided funding or has worked with E.T. Mars to help create this drug.
More about the suspects & plot
The Dead Man's Chest large group murder mystery game

The Dead Man's Chest

  • Plot Summary: 1857, New Orleans. This Mardi Gras Ball will become a swashbuckling pirate adventure to search for a dead man’s treasure chest.
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Mardi Gras Ball is optional but please note the year is 1857 so costumes will probably need to be rented. You can move it to modern day but the whole pirate theme will lose some of it’s fun.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: None
More about the suspects & plot
The Demise Of The Downhome Dealers large group murder mystery game

The Demise of the Downhome Dealers

  • Plot Summary: Major Country and Western stars Dixie Diver and the Downhome Dealers have come home to Mossy Bottom, Texas to announce the signing of their new contract with Good Ole Boys Records.
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • No singing required (unless you want to).
  • You can put this in any era you choose. Keep it in modern day or have it take place in the early 1940’s (Depression era) – think “O Brother, Where Art Thou”, the movie starring George Clooney.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. A character gets drunk. There are references to a woman turning tricks. There is a single woman who thinks she’s pregnant (she’s not).
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: You can eliminate any reference to the woman turning tricks. The drunk character needs to be able to drink in his misery. The allegedly pregnant woman must stay in the script as is. She is actually quite innocent of any sexual act.
More about the suspects & plot
The Mafia Murders

The Mafia Murders

  • Plot Summary: Circa 1920’s. Someone in the family is out to destroy the Godfather. So much for loyalty to “da boss”.
  • Requires 7 to 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Great choice for your holiday party – make it A Very Mafia Christmas.
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders and killings. Gangsters.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: None.
  • Corporate adaptation: Our Godfather is taking over your company or forming an alliance with your company – you’ll all be one big “family”.
More about the suspects & plot
Halloween large group murder mystery game

Thirst For Blood

  • Plot Summary: Devil’s Gulch is cursed which makes its annual Halloween costume party doomed.
  • You can also do this one anytime of the year by changing the party to The Annual Groundhog Day Gala or The Annual Turnip Festival Gala, etc. It’s a great choice for Friday the 13th!
  • Requires 8 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • Alternate Title: The Mystery of Devil’s Gulch
  • RATED: PG-13
  • CONTAINS: Murders. Occult and paranormal theme.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: None.
More about the suspects & plot
Vintage Murder large group murder mystery game with wine theme

Vintage Murder

  • Plot Summary: An historical winery is forced to go up for sale and 6 people – some wine lovers, some not – would kill to get their hands on it.
  • You can put this in any era you choose.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. One character has a bottle of beer he drinks from.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: None.
  • Corporate adaptation: A corporate meeting or incentive trip to the winery.
More about the suspects & plot
What Happened To Sam Disney large group mystery game

What Happened to Sam Disney?

  • Plot Summary: Gotham City has a mysterious benefactor. Or they did. Now he’s gone missing and it’s up to youto find him!
  • No murders, kidnapping only. Also includes a short, 15 minute scavenger hunt to find 5 clues.
  • Requires 6 people to play the prime suspects. For groups of 20 or more people.
  • RATED: PG
  • CONTAINS: Murders. A psychic character. A gambling addiction.
  • SUGGESTED ALTERNATIVES: The psychic can have an imaginary friend and think she’s psychic. The gambling addiction can be changed to a shopping addiction.
More about the suspects & plot

Instantly download our fun and challenging large group murder mystery game themes!

Budget friendly! Only $24.99 – $39.99. Step by step instructions and more included.